Disciplinary Modelling

Making expert thinking visible through staged construction of artefacts on the board

Disciplinary modelling is a teaching technique where the teacher makes visible — through the staged construction of an artefact on the board, often accompanied by think-aloud and checking for understanding — the specific reasoning that characterises their discipline.

The diagram should tell the story even without the teacher's voice — staged construction reveals reasoning that a finished diagram cannot.

The models below cover History and Geography across KS3, using a range of artefact types: box-and-arrow chains, two-column comparisons, claim-evidence-counter structures, radial diagrams, nested boxes, spectra, and Venn diagrams. Each is a complete teaching sequence — think-alouds, construction stages, checking questions, and delivery guidance.

This collection is an experiment in using AI to explore the problem space of disciplinary modelling — generating, testing, and refining models across subjects, reasoning types, and artefact structures. The models are starting points for discussion, not finished products.

History — Year 7

16 models
How Strong Was Henry VII in 1485?
ComparisonLow
Henry VII's Centralisation — The Trap of a Weak Claim
Causal ChainLow
Was the English Reformation Inevitable?
Causal ChainLow
How Far Did the Tudors Change England?
Hierarchy & StructureLow
How Remarkable Was the Ottoman Empire in 1500?
ImplicationLow
The Ivory Bangle Lady — Evidence and Diversity in Roman Britain
ContradictionLow
Henry II and Thomas Becket
Chain of ReasoningLow
Elizabeth's Legitimacy — Why Her Right to Rule Was Questioned
Chain of ReasoningLow
Elizabeth and Gender — Expectations vs Strategy
ComparisonLow
Elizabeth's Marriage Question — What If She Had Married?
CounterfactualLow
Elizabeth's Religious Settlement — Protestant or Catholic?
ClassificationMedium
The Spanish Armada — Why Did Spain Lose?
ContradictionLow
The Golden Age — Claim Under Pressure
ContradictionLow
Was Elizabeth's Reign Always a Golden Age?
Argument & CounterLow
The Tilbury Speech — How Do We Know She Said This?
Chain of ReasoningLow
Two Descriptions of Elizabeth — Why Do These Sources Disagree?
ComparisonLow

History — Year 9

1 model
Life in the Trenches — Constant Horror?
ContradictionLow

Geography — Year 7

8 models
Rural vs Urban — Where Does the Boundary Fall?
ClassificationLow
Migration — Push and Pull Together
Chain of ReasoningLow
Does the Burgess Model Fit a Real UK City?
ContradictionLow
Urban Problems — One Issue Creates Another
Chain of ReasoningLow
Why China and Not the UK for Manufacturing?
ComparisonLow
Primary, Secondary, Tertiary — Where Does the Boundary Fall?
ClassificationLow
Where Does the £1000 Go? — Layers Inside the Price
StructuresLow
Is China Still the 'Perfect' Place to Manufacture?
ContradictionLow

Geography — Year 8

5 models
Somerset Floods 2014 — Just the Rain?
Chain of ReasoningMedium
Erosion vs Weathering — Same Thing, Different Name?
ComparisonLow
From Meander to Ox-Bow Lake — The River That Cuts Itself Off
Chain of ReasoningLow
River Speed — Fastest Where It's Steepest?
ContradictionLow
Permeability vs Porosity — Same Thing, Different Word?
ComparisonLow

Geography — Year 9

1 model
River Erosion — Waterfall and Gorge Formation
Chain of ReasoningLow